Do I want an upright or a canister vacuum?
The most important factor is which style you like to use—there are excellent machines and really lousy machines in both categories. Since your needs, preferences and cleaning habits are a big factor in which style you will be partial to, with a little research and expert instruction you can get an excellent vacuum in either an upright or a canister. I will discuss this more below after a general discussion of the characteristics of uprights and canisters.
Historically uprights are better for carpet and canisters are better for hard surface floors and hose attachments. These are generalities that aren’t quite so true in today’s marketplace, but they are still significant factors in this decision. Newer uprights are better than the old styles for both hard floor cleaning and easy use attachments. Still, canisters are easier to use for the hose and they are significantly better on hard floors. For that reason, many professionals will recommend a canister to households that have 50% or more hard floors and an upright if you have mostly wall-to-wall carpet.
In addition, canisters are much better for getting under beds and furniture with low clearance and for above the floor cleaning. Canisters are harder to store and unless you have a big closet you need to attach the hose and power nozzle every time you use it. One of the biggest complaints about canisters is the main unit that pulls behind catches on wall corners and legs of furniture
Uprights are less expensive for the same cleaning power and durability as a comparable canister. Why? There are more parts in a canister. They need a really tough hose because you are pulling it around by the hose all the time. Plus, there are all the electrical connections on the hose that power the rug attachment which also has a second motor that adds to the cost. So, if price is a big factor an upright may be the way to go. For all the same reasons uprights tend to hold up better than canisters. There are simply more things to go wrong in a canister. However, depending on the manufacturer, some of the most durable vacuums are canisters.
As far as carpet cleaning—the very best uprights still clean carpet better than any canister, particularly in the lower price ranges. The differences are not that great anymore, but it is still the case. The ability of an upright to vibrate particles to the surface is difficult to achieve in a canister vacuum. For more on that see our article on agitation and cleaning. Having said that, there are plenty of canisters that will clean carpet better than many uprights.
Once again, the biggest factor is your personal preference. I’ve been in this business over thirty years and it has been proven to me time and again—there are canister people and there are upright people. Some people don’t really care which they use but most people do have at least a bit of a preference. I have seen many, many people that have switched styles and realized they hate using the new upright or canister they were so excited about. If you are person who cleans thoroughly every time you vacuum—one who likes to clean high and under and behind regularly, consider a canister. If your so busy it’s hard to find time to get the vacuum out of the closet and clean the middle of the floor then an upright could be for you. Obviously it’s your decision—there are simply too many variables to make complete generalizations, so, talk to a professional, and make sure you can try the vacuum on your carpet and other surfaces to see how it performs for you.
leroy :: Jul.02.2007 ::
Vacuums ::
1 Comment, add yours »